
Don’t Judge Me For Trying
Spring is in the air, and spring is in my step (the knee replacement recovery going very well), so I thought I’d fire up the M3 and go for a top-down drive. Granted, I only started it once in January, and the battery was low, but surely a jump from the big Merc and all would be good. But it wasn’t. My excellent CarMax service tech Ryan suggested leaving the cars attached for a bit to add juice to the BMW, and while that made the cockpit lights and dash work, it would not fire up. The Mercedes became the most expensive trickle charger ever. I summoned MaxCare roadside assistance, and Tony brought a 240 amp battery pack that jumped the BMW, but it totally died when I attempted to drive it and charge up the system. So he towed it to CarMax, and we shall see if there’s anything more to the problem than a two-year-old dead battery.

Last year, I used the springtime solar eclipse as an excuse to write about 10 convertible unicorns. Today, my broken M3 is my motivation. My criteria, as always, are arbitrary: Fun, fast, cheap, and not too common. (It sounds like my ideal date in high school.) I ditched Miatas and Minis not because they aren’t good cars; there are just too many of them out there. I will run through these 12 unicorns quickly, from cheapest to most expensive.
Budget Drop Top

Let’s start with the least defensible convertible, a 2014 Chrysler 200 Touring. Why is it here? It’s the cheapest convertible on CarMax lots nationwide. (I’m leaving out the Fiat 500 “convertibles” that are really soft top moon roofs.) Last year, I included one on my list, and the quotes from the Car and Driver review are too good not to recycle, “Like a single-issue candidate, the Chrysler 200 convertible has stumped on one appeal. In the car’s case, it’s that the top goes down.”

CarMax lists this car as equipped with “The Basics” because it has no noteworthy equipment. It gets worse before it gets better. The car doesn’t even have the V6 from last year’s recommendation; it has the 172 horsepower four-banger under the hood. It also has over 100,00 miles on it. What’s the positive?

It’s a convertible. And a drive in good weather with the top down will raise your mood by 50%, even in a shitty car. I believe everyone should own a convertible at least once in their life. If you don’t want to spend a lot to own an extra car just to drive top down, this one is for you. It sold for $21,000 new and is half that. I wouldn’t spend anything on MaxCare, not because this Chrysler is all that reliable, but because it’s just so cheap that if it breaks down, just push it into a ditch and buy something else. And if you think it’s an undesirable car at the moment, someone has it on reserve here in Southlake, Georgia!
Stock No: 26436621 VIN: 1C3BCBEB9EN112235

A More Legitimate Daily

Here’s another entry-level convertible that’s a whole lot more lovable. A 2014 BMW 428i. It’s a hard-top convertible, which I love a whole lot more than a sometimes noisy soft top (I’ve owned both). It’s a BMW. An “Ultimate Driving Machine,” as they say. It’s not a boy racer, no M3, just a credible topless driving car. This could easily be a four-season daily driver. Love the gold color. Too bad it’s not the old man gold over cream my generation so loves.

The BMW 428i doesn’t have many more features than the Chrysler 200, but it is by far more of a driver’s car. It also has a four-cylinder motor, but at 2.0 liters, the turbo makes 240 horsepower and runs to 60 mph in the mid-five-second range. Years ago, I had a 225 horsepower 330Ci convertible and never understood how BMW coaxed such acceleration out of little motors.

This 11-year-old BMW sold new for about $43,000 and is under $15k now. It’s got 83,000 miles and may need MaxCare as its systems age. It’s here in Norcross, Georgia. Not reserved!
Stock No: 26784455 VIN: WBA3V7C5XEP770684

EOS, Greek Goddess of the Dawn (or a unique Golf Cabriolet?)

The BMW 428i convertible is nice, but the VW Eos is unique. Based on the Golf platform, this diminutive hard-top convertible was sold in the US from 2006 to 2015, and this one is a last-year model. Its claim to fame is that it includes a fully accessible sunroof, the only one of its kind. I sat in one once, although I never drove it, and was surprised there was enough room for my 6’4″ frame. I just was never secure enough to buy one.

CarMax lists this car as “Loaded,” although it’s about the same inside as the 200 and 428. The 2.0-liter motor makes 200 horsepower and runs to 60 in 6.5 seconds, which ain’t awful, but that’s not why you’re buying this car. It’s all around a decent little second car with acceptable fuel economy, a low price, and a convertible with a sunroof!

This 2015 Eos sold new for maybe $36,000 and has very low mileage for a 10-year-old car. It’s less than $20k now and reserved here in Daytona, Florida. CarMax has a couple of very nice Eos, so there’s no need to wait on this one!
Stock No: 26578564 VIN: WVWBW8AHXFV002862

Nicht der Buick Deines Vaters

Put the 2017 Buick Cascada Sport Touring in the same category as the VW Eos – an attractive little German convertible, albeit a soft top, good for around-town top-down driving, but not much for “sport” or “touring.” Yes, the Buick Cascada is really a German Opel manufactured in Poland. The car sold as an Opel, Vauxhaul, Holden, and Buick from 2013 to 2019 (only 2016-2019 in the USA). It was the first Buick convertible since the 1991 Reatta.

The Buick has heated seats and a heated steering wheel, but it has only a handful of features despite being listed as “Loaded” by CarMax. It’s a two-owner car, and you can see from the photo below one of those owners badly needed their fingernails trimmed.

The Cascada got lukewarm reviews in the USA. The 1.6-liter turbo motor made 200 horsepower, like the Eos, but lagged to 60 mph in 7.5 seconds. Top speed was 130 mph. Although we don’t drive at top speed much in soft top convertibles, do we? They’re a bit noisy, top-up or top-down.

The 2017 Buick Cascada is probably an acceptable car for seasonal commuting or a spin to the vineyard for a riesling. The car sold new for maybe $34,000 – a ding at the time for not being competitively priced – and is selling at two-thirds that now. Interestingly (to me), MaxCare is only offered to a cap of 125,000 miles on German cars, but as a Buick, this German car is available with a 150,000-mile ceiling. Same thing with the Jeep Renegade, made in Italy. Higher ceiling as an “American” car. And while we’re at it, how about the Fiat 124, made in Japan, limited to 125,000 miles, while the Mazda Miata, also made in Japan and pretty much the same car, gets 150,000? You’d think CarMax would know better.
The Buick Cascada is reserved here in Killeen, TX.
Stock No: 26968832 VIN: W04WJ3N56HG037175

Why?

Nissan billed the Murano Cross Cabriolet as “the world’s first all-wheel drive crossover convertible. ” It was sold from 2011 to 2014, and we have here a final-year model. I chuckled at The Truth About Car’s introduction back in the day as they headed to the California media introduction. “If you’ve ever been to a topless beach, you know the basic problem: you expect a bunch of topless Jags and Maseratis, but what you actually get is this, the Nissan Murano CrossCabriolet. Four thousand pounds of roly-poly crossover blessed with the totally misguided belief that people want to see it with its top off. We’ll keep a corner of our eye on this as the LA Auto Show kicks off… but we’ll be sure to avoid eye contact.“

Yes, the Murano is AWD and has the only available option—$500 leather seats that are heated—yet it seems like every other Murano inside. It’s not bad—just dated. I like to play a game on road trips, thinking, “When was the last time I saw a XXXXX on the road?”. This month’s Car and Driver has a piece on the Merkur Xr4ti on the back page, which I owned once (a Merkur, not Car and Driver), and I can honestly say I haven’t seen one on the road in over 25 years. Since I started this piece on convertibles, I’ve seen two Murano Cross Cabriolets out and about in Virginia. More fascinating, over 42,000 Xr4ti’s were imported, but only 6,000 Murano Cross Cabriolets. Makes it a unicorn, yes? And more reliable than a Merkur by far.

As an SUV, the Murano lacks trunk space because of the convertible mechanism, and the back seat, while spacious, is hard to access because of the massive two-door configuration. It’s not an ugly car top-up or top-down, and there is the uniqueness of tooling around in an SUV convertible if it’s just me and the wife and an overnight bag in the back seat. Except she hates convertibles.

The Murano Cross Cabriolet “sports” a 3.5-liter six-cylinder with 265 horsepower. It’ll run to 60 mph in about eight seconds, which makes it the slowest, I think, in my selection. The Murano sold new for maybe $42,000. It is coming soon to Phoenix-West Valley.
Stock No: 26812848 VIN: JN8AZ1FY6EW301037

$7,000 More for Legit Street Cred

The first batch of convertibles are decent daily drivers, but this 2014 Jaguar XK will make folks think you are on a different level of affluence. This was once an $85,000 luxury car, and you can have it for the price of a Camry. That’s the whole premise of this blog. Lord knows how many XK’s I’ve blogged about, and I still wish I had pulled the trigger on an XKR, and yes, F-Types have depreciated almost to the point of XK’s, but these are beautiful cars. Granted, the top-up version of the XK is not as sleek as the hard top, but it ain’t ugly.

The XK comes with heated and air-conditioned seats, a heated steering wheel, and a Bowers & Wilkins audio system, and it just feels like a high-end British touring car. And it’s green over tan—about as good as it gets for 2014. The motor is a naturally aspirated 5.0 liter, 385 horsepower V-8, good for a 5.1-second 0-60 mph run and 155 mph top end. This is the first enthusiast convertible on the list.

This Jaguar XK is currently reserved here in Serramonte, California. It also has very low miles for an 11-year-old car. Buy the Maxcare.
Stock No: 26703326 VIN: SAJWA4GB1ELB53406

Wait! An Even Better Euro-Unicorn!

If I weren’t such a slacker, this car would warrant a blog post all by itself. It’s a 2014 Mercedes SLK55 AMG hardtop convertible. It costs less than $30,000. It has a naturally aspirated hand-built V8 motor that my friend Hans covets. It can go from 0 to 60 in 4.6 seconds and has a top speed of 155 mph. This is a driver’s car in and out.

In CarMax’s bizarre lingo, the car is listed as “loaded” even though it has the same features as everything else. It does have the Mercedes only air scarf neck heaters from the headrest. I love the idea. I also was puzzled by CarMax’s suggestion that the car has a “Rear Entertainment System. It includes one or more rear seat screens and might support Blu-ray, DVD, HDMI, or USB.” There are no rear seats.

The 2014 Mercedes SLK55 AMG was sold new for about $65,000. It was a bargain then, and it remains so now at less than half that, with really low miles. Of course, I would add Maxcare and drive the snot out of it—if I fit into it. It’s currently reserved here in Phoenix-West Valley, Arizona.
Stock No: 27001395 VIN: WDDPK7FA2EF077576

(This One Doesn’t Count)

Since we have an SLK55, I thought I’d include the ad for this 2022 SL55 AMG, the most expensive convertible on CarMax lots at the moment. It’s a beautiful car, although with a soft top. It has a 469 horsepower V-8 under the hood and every modern luxury feature—even the air scarf! It’s here in Kearny Mesa, California, if you want it.
The Convertible That Started It All

I spotted this 2015 BMW 650 I on the CarMax page a good two weeks ago; I was impressed with the tan-over-blue exterior, baseball glove leather interior, decent motor, low miles, and relatively low price. I thought, “This will make a good piece on springtime and convertible unicorns!” Then the road to hell….”I wonder what other cool convertibles are out there? Maybe I’ll do a longer piece with just a few more cars. I’ll keep my commentary limited and get it to press quickly.” If you’re a regular reader, you’ve heard this before. This year, a road trip to Ohio to see the kickoff of March Madness interrupted my writing, followed by too many games on TV when I returned. So here we are.

This car almost has it all: heated, cooling, and massaging seats, Harman Kardon audio, but no auto cruise control. Under the hood, a 4.4-liter twin-turbo V8 with 445 horsepower gets you to 60 mph in 4.5 seconds and a top-end (governor limited) of 155 mph. This, my friends, is a sport touring automobile. Pretty close to the ultimate driving machine, at least with a soft top.

This 2015 BMW 650i is a four-owner car that spent most of its life in and around my hometown of Baltimore. A few years back, it suffered a door ding in Delaware. The car has surprisingly low miles and is now for sale here in Gaithersburg, Maryland.
Stock No: 26927751 VIN: WBAYP9C54FD169687

The British Murano?

Didn’t we just do this? If it didn’t make sense from Japan, why would it from the United Kingdom? This AWD convertible SUV is, in fact, a 2019 Land Rover Range Rover Evoque SE Dynamic. Long name for a short SUV. Conceptually the same as the Murano, it is a far more high-end version of a convertible SUV.
Land Rover design chief Gerry McGovern said, “It’s the first luxury SUV convertible. There have been other convertible SUVs, but not a luxury execution. We’ll take buyers from other luxury cars. Most Evoque customers came from premium brands, but had never owned an SUV before“. The convertible Evoque was sold from 2017 to 2019, and while there were hints of a 2020 facelift, I can’t find any confirmation on the net of the model making it beyond 2019. And I’ve wasted another half hour looking!

This Evoque is almost the most modern convertible here, I guess, with Meridian audio, heated seats, a heated steering wheel, and Apple CarPlay. It’s powered by a 2.0-liter turbo four, with 237 horsepower and a mid-seven second 0-60 mph time. Unlike the Murano, Land Rover bills this SUV as equally capable off-road as its other models. Something to be said for wind and mud through the hair!

Selling new for perhaps $58,000, this is a nice two-door SUV that happens to be a convertible. I think Land Rover design chief Gerry McGovern overstated the demand above. Owners looking for production numbers think maybe 10,000 were sold. I think that’s optimistic based on my scientific data analytics of having never seen one on the road. This one is shipping to Columbus Sawmill, Georgia. Here’s the link. CarMax also has two others if you’re in a hurry!
Stock No: 27029985 VIN: SALVC5RX0KH342314

Muscle Car Mania

The 2013 Chevrolet Camaro ZL1 has the most horsepower of the convertibles on my list, although it’s not the fastest. At $39k, it’s a bargain. This is the fifth generation Camaro, and 2013 was the first year for the ZL1.

This 12-year-old Camaro has seat heaters, a heads-up display, remote start, and navigation. What makes it special is the 6.2 liter supercharged V-8 power plant, first produced for the 2009 Cadillac CTS-V. It pumps 580 horsepower through the rear wheels and hits 60 mph in 4.1 seconds. The top speed is a crazy 184 mph. The sixth generation Camaro ZL1 bumps power up to 650 horsepower! It’ll cost you another $13,000 to upgrade from this 2013 ZL1 to a 2016 to get all that oomph.

The 2013 Camaro ZL1 convertible sold new for around $60,000. This one is only $39k and has very low miles on it. MaxCare is available for another five years and 130,000 miles (to 150k). Right now, it’s on reserve here in Gaithersburg, Maryland – same as the BMW 650i above. Go drive them both and choose?
Stock No: 26838548 VIN: 2G1FL3DP8D9806764

Camaro or Corvette?

I don’t know a lot about C7 Corvettes, or any Corvettes, or really any cars for that matter, so when I was trying to learn if this Corvette Stingray Z51 had the performance package, not only was I unsuccessful, but I found that Corvette folks are uncertain on how to tell a Stingray is even a Z51 without scanning the QR code on the door sill. I cannot confirm any emblems or visual cues. So, I must take CarMax’s word that this is a Z51. They have misidentified cars before, sometimes in our favor.

The “base” Z51 still offers a 6.2-liter naturally aspirated V-8 with 460 horsepower that will crack 60 mph in less than four seconds. Less horsepower than the Camaro ZL1 and also less weight. The top end is allegedly 190 mph, and it’ll pull over 1g in lateral handling. The Z51 package gets you splitters, better brakes, better exhaust, and better suspension. And apparently gobs of carbon fiber all over the interior. The Stingray has heated and air-conditioned seats, a heads-up display, and Bose audio. And the hood opens from the windshield side, cool like the Jaguar.

When new, the 2014 Chevrolet Corvette Stingray Z51 was in the mid-$50,000 range—more if it had the performance package—less than the Camaro ZL1. It hasn’t depreciated much. It’s currently reserved in Jackson, Mississippi here.
Stock No: 26481858 VIN: 1G1YM3D72E5124743

Finally, a Manual Mustang

CarMax has 1,200 convertibles for sale today, out of about 58,000 cars overall, and only 227 of those convertibles have a manual transmission. Of those, the most interesting one to me was this 2020 Ford Mustang GT Premium, also the newest and most modern, if you will.

The Mustang has air conditioned and heated seats, a heated steering wheel, auto cruise control, Apple CarPlay, and even not one but TWO smart keys. Pretty well equipped convertible. I don’t get the Carroll Shelby floor and trunk mats, though.

The Mustang has the 5.0 liter naturally aspirated V-8 pushing 460 ponies. It ran 0-60 in 4.2 seconds and would max out at 155 mph, right behind the Chevrolets. It’s a clean car with three owners already – owners who drove it very little. The manufacturer warranty has expired and I don’t think MaxCare would even be needed for such a tried and true platform.

The only disappointing thing is the lack of depreciation. The car sold new for only $6,000 or so more than it’s offered here. Here’s the link. The car is currently on its way to Gainesvile, Florida.
Stock No: 27155931 VIN: 1FATP8FF7L5156665

The BMW M3 is back on the road! The battery needed replacement after all. Thanks to Ryan of CarMax for getting me back on the road!